I’ve been entertaining this for year now!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Caterham is doing a build with JUST 240 HP. They project 4S 0-60. So, a base Tesla transaxle would give some pretty staggering numbers in this car. The battery energy density is going to be the challenge. The ICE engine and transaxle in this car is pretty light. I know a lot of other builds are ending up lighter when BEV converting classic cars like the Teslarosa etc.. but I find it hard to believe that you are going to have any reasonable range and not increase the weight or totally screw up the weight balance. From what I can see most of the mass would be in front of the steering rack. Eeeek.I've thought about this since I joined this forum and was even criticized for considering it as an option back then.
In the past 10+ years, and from the successful conversions I've seen with other Toyotas, it has gone from a proof of concept science project to entirely feasible. The cost is still high but there are plenty of options and price points. There was a Matrix with the conversion a LONG time ago and more recently an AW11 in New Zealand. The most impressive part of the AW11 was the torque he had just zipping around at low speeds from a dead stop.
Range will always be the biggest issue, but even a old Nissan Leaf motor would be incredible in this car. @psipwrd Are you something of a scientist yourself?
Not a scientist, but I was an electrician in the Air Force!I've thought about this since I joined this forum and was even criticized for considering it as an option back then.
In the past 10+ years, and from the successful conversions I've seen with other Toyotas, it has gone from a proof of concept science project to entirely feasible. The cost is still high but there are plenty of options and price points. There was a Matrix with the conversion a LONG time ago and more recently an AW11 in New Zealand. The most impressive part of the AW11 was the torque he had just zipping around at low speeds from a dead stop.
Range will always be the biggest issue, but even a old Nissan Leaf motor would be incredible in this car. @psipwrd Are you something of a scientist yourself?
Well, how heavy are we talking for newer batteries in order to achieve reasonable range (200 miles?). I can't imagine we are talking heavier than the 1zz, trans, gas. Plus you could distribute the weight closer to center in the mk3, eh?I'm a physics professor and an electric car enthusiast. I own a Nissan Leaf, Chevy Volt, and plug-in hybrid Cmax (In addition to my spyder.) 15 years ago, before it was a thing, I converted a motorcycle to electric power using a golf cart motor and controller. Unfortunately, I used heavy lead-acid batteries, so it kind of sucked (low range, moderate acceleration and a top speed of 70 mph). If I were ever in a position to buy a super car, it would probably be electric. I've even fantasized about putting a Nissan Leaf motor in the MR2 when the 1zz finally dies.
At the end of they day, I think I'll probably stay with gas power on the MR2 for two reasons:
1) In the future we are all moving to electric if we want to or not. There will always be the option of buying a fast electric car. We are living at the end of the era of enthusiast gas-powered cars. I plan to enjoy it.
2) Heavy batteries ruined my electric motorcycle. Modern batteries are a lot better than what I used, but batteries are still too heavy. The MR2 is fun because it is light.
But, if you want to convert yours to electric, I'll love watching the build.
Am Electrical Engineer (have not done a lot of research on this other than a slight desire to build an electric Atom)how heavy are we talking for newer batteries in order to achieve reasonable range (200 miles?)
I'm with you. Conversions are for the cool factor not performance. Like making a classic Vette usable with modern reliability.The EV drive footprint is so different than the ICE drive footprint that I think that to work well, an EV would have to be designed from the ground up, and conversions will be relegated to novelty status. It is still worth doing, and someone needs to be the pioneer, but I would regulate my expectations.
There is going to be a tremendous amount of developmental progress in EV equipment now that there is some money in it, and in a few years the field may look very different. Prices will come down, and we are very near to the point where multiple gear transmissions will be unnecessary, if we are not there already. I think that the final solution will be an all EV drive with an onboard fuel cell recharger to extend range.