[cyclehead]

Eight black fenders listed on car-part.com currently.

 

[Sisyphus]

These guys have good pricing and shipping rates. Most important they take PayPal

 

[Galo]

Definitely good prices.

 

[Superbideas]

I want the paint to somewhat match the car with 80k miles but new is an option, thanks!

 

[Sisyphus]

I want the paint to somewhat match the car with 80k miles but new is an option, thanks!

If you check, like on ebay, there are outfits that specialize in oem paints in shake cans. Good stuff. Kind of pricey these days. But a can each of primer, base, and 2 stage clear coat should be about 50 dollars. Toyota has for decades used extremely high quailty paint I doubt you'll notice much fade (except maybe with red?).
Besides if there is significant fading it will be nearly impossible to find a fender that's faded in a similar manor. Let alone a straight one. In my experience used body parts are false economy. If your in a medium or large metro area there are automotive paint suppliers (yes some auto paint suppliers can put it in shake cans, call around) that might, for a price, mix a custom shade to match your fade. Maybe even consider having a shop paint your fender before you install it.

 

[FormInFunction]

I want the paint to somewhat match the car with 80k miles but new is an option, thanks!

A used panel will never color match. Your best bet is used/ new panel, detail the rest of the car, then have a shop paint the replacement panel to match.

Look at any Solar yellow car, most of the the VIN matching panels don't even match each other...they look like very subtle harlequin Spyders [emoji6]

 

[Superbideas]

You guys are awesome! Thanks for the tips!
Found a local guy with black spyder parts he pulled from his first spyder. Picked up a faded fender with slight flaking with primer intact that I’m going to refinish.